Government  Health IT
TwitterFacebookLinkedIn
  • Home
  • Topics
    • Cloud Computing
    • Election 2012
    • Electronic Health Record
    • ePrescribing
    • Health Information Exchange (HIE)
    • Meaningful Use
    • Medicaid
    • Medicare
    • Military Health
    • Mobile/ Wireless
    • NHIN
    • Policy & Legislation
    • Population Health
    • Privacy and Security
    • Quality and Safety
    • Telehealth
    • Workforce Management
  • Issues
    • Sept/Oct 2011
    • July/August 2011
    • May/June 2011
    • March/April 2011
    • Jan/Feb 2011
    • Nov/Dec 2010
  • Webinars
    • Upcoming Webinars
    • On Demand Webinars
  • White Papers
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • RSS
  • Slideshows
  • Videos
  • Podcasts
  • Newsletters
  • Advertise
  • LOGIN
  • REGISTER
  • SUBSCRIBE
Home » Blogs » Election 2012 | Population Health

  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • RSS Icon
  

Tweet

Is this week's House vote to repeal ACA merely symbolic?

July 11, 2012 | Tom Sullivan, Editor

Suggested Content

  • Governors weigh HIX options
  • Frist tells governors to start up HIXs now
  • HIMSS EHR Association fires back at GOP Senators calling for MU reboot
  • Tavenner confirmation triggers applause from industry

Related Resources

  • Advanced Text Mining Improves Medicare Advantage Coding
  • Enabling Data as a Service in Healthcare
  • Best Practices to Deploy ECM Technologies: Ensure Decisions are Made Based on all the Information, not a Portion of it

It may take until November before Wednesday’s House hearing on a bill to repeal the Affordable Care Act results in anything more than political grandstanding by anti-Obamacare Representatives – which won’t stop some Senators from trying to follow suit and holding their own vote.

"This is to make it crystal clear to the American people that really the final decision is in their hands,” Rep Tom Cole, (R-Oklahoma) said of the House session slated for Wednesday.

And Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky) said he is hoping to have another chance to repeal the Affordable Care Act in the Senate. "I would remind you all that we had that vote in 2011. Every single Republican voted to repeal it,” The Hill reports McConnell saying at a press conference Tuesday. “We believe it's appropriate to have that vote again and we'll be working to get that kind of vote in the near future."

[See also: After the Supreme Court, it's time for a Health IT Orthodoxy 2.0.]

And, then, let’s just say that both the House and Senate vote for a bill to repeal the ACA, well, President Obama would veto that. Which has Democrats asking: Why hold another repeal vote when politicians have already voted on it so many times previously and, now, the Supreme Court has upheld it as constitutional.

Rep. Louise Slaughter, (D-NY) said Tuesday on the House floor that, “Never in the history of this Congress has anybody voted this many times on a single issue. And why? Because we don't have anything else to do."

Echoing a rampant Republican sentiment by calling Obamacare “nothing short of economic malpractice,” Rep Nan Hayworth (R-NY) added, according to a CBS report, that “we can and must do better.”

That notion has Republicans toeing the Romney line this week and saying that the only way to repeal the ACA is to vote Obama out of the White House. While Romney has been mostly quiet about healthcare leading up to the House vote, Obama said on the campaign trail that the health reform law is the “right thing to do."

[Related: Why standard campaign tactics don't apply to healthcare.]

But is all this just a political exercise in futility and waste simply to make a point?

“I think it’s more than symbolic,” Cole, the Oklahoma Rep. said. “Look, we’re going to actually see some Democrats who voted against repeal the last time move and join us. Plus, you’ll see obviously every single Republican vote ‘no.’ It makes clear what a partisan bill this is, how unpopular it is, and the opposition is bi-partisan. Only the support is partisan.”

Whether or not that’s true will be borne out on the House floor, to be certain. Among the American public, however, a Washington Post/ABC News Poll found that since the Supreme Court ruling, voter support for the ACA has undergone “a sizable swing” from 39 in favor and 53 against to an even split of 47-47.

“While opinion tilts narrowly against the ruling, only 33 percent support repealing the whole law, which is Mitt Romney’s position and will get a vote in the House this week,” wrote Greg Sargent in the Washington Post’s Plum Line blog. “Thirty percent support repealing unspecified parts of it — which could reflect dislike of the mandate.”

For more of our politics coverage, visit Political Malpractice: Healthcare in the 2012 Election

Tom Sullivan
Editor of Government Health IT
Follow Tom on Twitter @GovHITeditor
Related Topics:
  • Election 2012
  • Population Health
  • ABC News
  • CBS
  • the Washington Post
  • Person Career
  • Quotation
  • healthcare
  • Congress
  • Greg Sargent
  • Louise Slaughter
  • Mitch McConnell
  • Nan Hayworth
  • Oklahoma
  • Republicans
  • Senate
  • Supreme Court
  • The Hill
  • the Washington Post
  • Tom Cole
  • Washington Post
  • White House

Reader Comments (0)Login to Post a Comment

Most Popular

Latest Headlines
Most Popular
  • Deloitte: Docs underutilize various health technologies
  • Commentary: How data sharing between AHLTA and VistA is possible
  • NYeC PHR design winners to shape public portal
  • Why modernizing state IT infrastructures is crucial for HIX
  • First HIE launching in greater Philadelphia
  • Is the presidential election healthcare's own perfect storm for EHRs?
  • Stage 2 meaningful use: Patient engagement and HIE
  • Doctors Using Electronic Health Records Provide Higher Quality Healthcare
  • Impacts of ACA and Massachusetts law still to be measured; some see costs falling
  • Why health execs don't understand the ROI of HIT
more Blog

WEBINARS AND WHITE PAPERS

  • WHITE PAPERS
    Enterprise-class API Patterns for Cloud & Mobile
  • WHITE PAPERS
    Cloud Computing in the Healthcare Environment
  • WHITE PAPERS
    New World Order: Effectively Securing Healthcare Data Through Secure Information Exchanges
  • WHITE PAPERS
    When Evolution Drives Revolution: The Cloud as a Business Model
  • WHITE PAPERS
    A Reference Architecture for Healthcare Benefit Exchange
More Resources
Syndicate content

HIMSS JOBMINE

  • Director of Clinical Applications - MidMichigan Health - Midland, MI
  • Information Services Director - Central Peninsula Hospital - Soldotna, AK
  • Director, Marketing and Business Development - Vermont Information Technology Leaders, Inc. - Burlington, VT
  • CIO - Bend Memorial Clinic - Bend, Oregon
  • Director of Clinical Transformation - Agnesian Healthcare - Fond du Lac, WI
more jobs
receive news by email

Marketplace

  • Home
  • Resource Central
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • Mobile Site
  • Advertise
  • RSS
  • About
  • Site map
  • Privacy Policy
Follow Government Health IT on TwitterLike Government Health IT on FacebookJoin Government Health IT on LinkedInRSS Subscriptions
BlogEvents
JobsMobile SiteMobile App
 
Healthcare IT NewsHealthcare Finance NewsHealthcare Payer NewsHIEWatch ICD10Watch mHIMSS PhysBizTech
©2013 MedTech Media Government Health IT is a publication of MedTech Media
Advertise About Us Privacy Policy